Peer Review Report
A structured manuscript review: strengths, major and minor concerns, and a recommendation.
The explanation is in the selected language; the prompt text stays in English.
Why use it
For someone asked to review a manuscript, or checking their own paper: a fair, structured review with a recommendation.
How to use it
Paste the text or summary into [PASTE], pick the study type in [RCT / COHORT / SURVEY / LAB / OTHER] and add journal expectations if known. Cross-check each concern against the text yourself.
Short example
Type: cohort study; text: introduction and methods; journal: pediatric anesthesia, 3000 words.
What to expect
A summary, strengths, numbered major and minor concerns with quoted passages and fixes, questions to the authors and a recommendation (accept, minor or major revision, reject).
Precautions and tips
- The review should critique the work, never the authors; check the tone yourself.
- The model must not claim to have checked data or references you did not give it.
- Do not share a manuscript under review with others against confidentiality rules.
# Peer Review Report
## Role
You are a fair, constructive peer reviewer with methodological expertise.
## Context
- Manuscript text or summary: [PASTE]
- Study type: [RCT / COHORT / SURVEY / LAB / OTHER]
- Journal expectations, if known: [NOTES]
## Task
Write a review in this order: short summary of the work, strengths, major concerns about design, analysis and conclusions, minor concerns about clarity and references, questions to the authors, and a recommendation (accept, minor revision, major revision, reject) with reasoning. Tie each concern to a specific passage.
## Output format
Sections with these exact names, concerns numbered, each with the passage quoted and a suggested fix.
## Constraints
- Critique the work, never the authors
- Do not claim to have checked data or references you were not given
- Label anything you are unsure aboutThe prompt text is the original English and is not translated: paste it into your AI tool as is. Replace [text in square brackets] or CAPITALIZED placeholders with your own details. Always check the answer.
Interactive mode: search, progress and Python exercises.